{"id":"4c216fc9-3f72-4186-a391-32cb1653f8c5","handoff_bundle_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","civitas_adjudication_id":null,"bundle_title":"Civitas governed bundle — 2026-05-11","status":"heartbeat_succeeded","final_verdict":null,"confidence_posture":null,"uncertainty_posture":null,"publishable_as_is":false,"revise_signal":false,"defer_signal":false,"escalate_signal":false,"scope_status":null,"fallback_status":null,"fallback_reason":null,"manual_review_required":false,"coverage":{"claims_assessed":0,"claims_partially_assessed":0,"claims_not_assessed":0,"scope_within_capability":false,"coverage_fraction":null},"submitted_by":"operator@orbital.local","submitted_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.113755Z","completed_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.199814Z","created_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.115027Z","verdict_rationale":null,"challenge_findings":[],"branch_governance_verdict":null,"branch_evidence_scorecard":null,"branch_comparison_scorecard":null,"branch_frontier_policy":null,"branch_search_nudge_posture":null,"branch_portfolio_posture":null,"branch_replay_trace":null,"orbital_tool_request_policy":null,"orbital_tool_requests":[],"orbital_tool_request_receipts":[],"branch_policy_variants":[],"branch_shadow_evaluations":[],"branch_outcome_memories":[],"branch_strategic_retrospectives":[],"branch_governance_receipt":null,"branch_policy_learning_receipt":{"contract_version":"orbital.branch.policy.learning.receipt.v1","receipt_id":"policy-learning-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","source_kind":"civitas_memory_review","recommended_posture":"tighten","reasons":["Historical branch failures or false convergence still justify a tighter policy posture.","Treat 'bundle' cautiously: 3 total memories, 1 poor-yield, 0 contamination, 0 false-novelty."],"memory_hook_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"],"linked_judgments":[],"challenge_summary":{"max_waste_score":0.8,"failure_hook_count":3,"top_failure_patterns":[{"count":3,"summary":"bundle occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"bundle","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"]}],"total_memory_records":3,"governance_disposition":null,"false_convergence_count":0,"repeated_false_novelty_classes":[],"historical_caution_branch_types":["bundle"],"repeated_contamination_patterns":[],"successful_disconfirming_patterns":[]},"future_hcm_hsam_insertion_points":{"note":"Reserved insertion points only; full HCM/HSAM shaping is not active.","active":false,"hcm_slot":"branch_policy_outcome_memory_v1","hsam_slot":"branch_family_pattern_memory_v1"},"issued_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197353750+00:00"},"civitas_8_evidence_refs":null,"request_payload":{"schema":"orbital.adjudication.bundle.v1","metadata":{"correlation_id":"4c216fc9-3f72-4186-a391-32cb1653f8c5","source_service":"orbital","submission_mode":"automatic"},"bundle_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","hold_reason":"eligibility_rules","packet_type":"governance_heartbeat","generated_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.113755+00:00","decision_state":"held","workspace_slug":"orbital"},"response_payload":{"schema":"civitas.orbital.adjudication.response.v1","coverage":{"claims_assessed":0,"branches_assessed":1,"coverage_fraction":1.0,"claims_assessed_ids":[],"claims_not_assessed":0,"claims_not_assessed_ids":[],"scope_within_capability":true,"derived_branch_artifacts":1,"claims_partially_assessed":0,"explicit_branch_artifacts":0,"ignored_or_weakly_assessed":["Replay metadata is incomplete, so downstream governance replay is only partially supported."],"claims_partially_assessed_ids":[]},"bundle_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","why_defer":["The leading branch is not plausible or evidenced enough to keep promoting without bounded correction.","Branch evidence remains too weak for a merge or confident continue decision.","Live evidence is below the orchestration floor, so Civitas abstains from deeper request issuance."],"why_revise":[],"branch_court":{"cases":[{"defense":{"claims":["Evidence sufficiency is 0.0/100 with 0 supporting reference(s).","Plausibility is 24.1/100 with admissibility 'unknown' and reliability 55.0/100."],"strength":{"band":"poor","score":11.6,"summary":"Defense strength reflects plausibility plus evidence sufficiency."}},"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","prosecution":{"claims":["Contradiction burden is 4.0/100 with 0 contradiction signal(s).","Contamination posture is 48.0/100 with source concentration 0 lane(s).","No explicit supporting evidence refs were supplied."],"strength":{"band":"low","score":27.9,"summary":"Prosecution strength reflects contradiction, contamination, urgency, and escalation posture."}},"branch_label":"bundle branch","significance":{"band":"low","score":33.8,"summary":"Significance rises when a branch is plausible enough to matter or risky enough to require governance attention."},"judge_decision":"suppress","judge_rationale":["The branch is not yet plausible or evidenced enough to keep promoting.","No extra contradiction signal was supplied beyond the bundle-level burden, so the judge stays bounded to provided inputs."],"required_actions":["Suppress '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' until stronger evidence or cleaner provenance arrives."]}],"bounded_scope":"Civitas ran a bounded three-role court on significant supplied branches only. It did not create or execute branches.","significant_branch_count":1},"defer_signal":true,"scope_limits":["Replay metadata is incomplete, so downstream governance replay is only partially supported."],"scope_status":"within_capability","why_escalate":[],"final_verdict":"deferred","revise_signal":false,"verdict_inputs":{"agent_entropy":0.7,"admissible_share":0.0,"acceptance_headroom":0.0,"agent_confidence_score":28.4,"agent_proposal_excerpt":"Based on that, perhaps we should consider: ORBITAL_BRANCH_ADJUDICATION bundle_kind=unknown bundle_id=39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\nBUNDLE bundle_kind=unknown bundle_id=39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e claim_count=0 intervention_c","bundle_ambiguity_score":50.0,"dominant_admissibility":"context_only","bundle_confidence_score":0.0,"bundle_uncertainty_score":100.0,"bundle_novelty_risk_score":50.0,"max_intervention_downside":35.0,"bundle_contradiction_score":0.0,"bundle_corroboration_score":0.0,"bundle_data_sparsity_score":50.0,"challenge_confidence_score":18.1,"challenge_uncertainty_score":42.4,"bundle_causal_weakness_score":60.0,"average_branch_evidence_score":0.0,"max_branch_contamination_score":48.0,"max_branch_contradiction_score":4.0,"min_intervention_reversibility":60.0,"bundle_evidence_sufficiency_score":0.0},"adjudication_id":"civitas-adj-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-1778399946197","branch_verdicts":["suppress","request_disconfirming_evidence","weak_evidence"],"escalate_signal":false,"fallback_status":null,"assumption_flags":[],"policy_challenge":{"replay_hints":["Replay the same branch scorecards, branch court decisions, and convergence cases before changing policy.","Policy challenge is bundle-local and should not be generalized without repeated bundle pressure."],"bounded_scope":"Civitas challenged branch-governance policy using only supplied bundle evidence and governance outputs. It did not own policy execution or branch generation.","challenge_items":[{"concern":{"band":"low","score":1.8,"summary":"Spawn-threshold pressure rises when contradiction is high but counter-branching is thin."},"rationale":["Max branch contradiction is 4.0/100 and request_counter_branch is absent."],"disposition":"retain","policy_area":"spawn_thresholds","current_posture":"balanced","recommended_adjustments":["Keep current spawn thresholds until contradiction pressure rises."]},{"concern":{"band":"low","score":19.0,"summary":"Fatigue pressure rises when many weak or sparse branches are still consuming governance attention."},"rationale":["1 significant branch court case(s) with 1 weak or quarantine posture(s)."],"disposition":"retain","policy_area":"fatigue_rules","current_posture":"balanced","recommended_adjustments":["Current fatigue gating is acceptable for this bundle."]},{"concern":{"band":"low","score":2.1,"summary":"Contradiction-weight pressure rises when contradiction remains high relative to promotion appetite."},"rationale":["Max contradiction is 4.0/100 while branch verdict set is [Suppress, RequestDisconfirmingEvidence, WeakEvidence]."],"disposition":"retain","policy_area":"contradiction_weighting","current_posture":"balanced","recommended_adjustments":["Keep contradiction weighting unchanged."]},{"concern":{"band":"low","score":28.8,"summary":"Contamination-penalty pressure rises when dirty branches survive too far into governance review."},"rationale":["Max contamination is 48.0/100; quarantine case present: no."],"disposition":"retain","policy_area":"contamination_penalty","current_posture":"balanced","recommended_adjustments":["Current contamination penalties are adequate for this bundle."]},{"concern":{"band":"low","score":0.0,"summary":"Audience-weighting pressure rises when committee friction and observed shifts are present but under-modeled."},"rationale":["0 blocker signal(s) and 0 audience/behavior shift signal(s) supplied."],"disposition":"retain","policy_area":"audience_weighting","current_posture":"balanced","recommended_adjustments":["Keep current audience weighting until stronger friction signals appear."]},{"concern":{"band":"high","score":64.4,"summary":"Promotion-criteria pressure rises when headroom, evidence, contradiction, and contamination are out of balance."},"rationale":["Acceptance headroom 0.0/100 with average branch evidence 0.0/100."],"disposition":"tighten","policy_area":"promotion_criteria","current_posture":"too-lenient","recommended_adjustments":["Tighten promotion criteria until contradiction and contamination pressure are reduced."]}],"overall_posture":"policy_stable_under_current_bundle"},"branch_scorecards":[{"source":"bundle","urgency":{"band":"low","score":35.0,"summary":"Urgency reflects intervention downside 35.0, reversibility 60.0, contradiction 4.0, uncertainty 100.0, and bounded heat pressure 0.0."},"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","branch_label":"bundle branch","plausibility":{"band":"poor","score":24.1,"summary":"Plausibility blends evidence 0.0, corroboration 0.0, mechanism 50.0, reliability 55.0, and admissibility 'unknown'."},"contradiction":{"band":"low","score":4.0,"summary":"Contradiction reflects direct burden 0.0, 0 contradiction signal(s), 0 disagreement-zone hit(s), and uncertainty 100.0."},"novelty_posture":{"band":"moderate","score":50.0,"summary":"Novelty posture reflects bundle novelty 50.0, branch corroboration 0.0, and source concentration 0."},"linked_claim_ids":[],"evidence_sufficiency":{"band":"poor","score":0.0,"summary":"Evidence sufficiency blends support 0.0, corroboration 0.0, reliability 55.0, and 0 distinct source lane(s)."},"contamination_posture":{"band":"moderate","score":48.0,"summary":"Contamination posture reflects admissibility 'unknown', 0 contamination signal(s), and 0 support reference(s)."},"escalation_suitability":{"band":"moderate","score":42.2,"summary":"Escalation suitability rises when contradiction, contamination, urgency, downside, or irreversibility dominate the branch posture."}}],"convergence_court":{"cases":[],"bounded_scope":"Civitas assessed convergence only among significant supplied branches. It did not infer hidden branches or retrieve extra evidence."},"publishable_as_is":false,"verdict_rationale":"Civitas judged 1 branch artifact(s) from Orbital bundle '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' (kind: unknown). Leading branch '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' scored plausibility 24.1/100, contradiction 4.0/100, evidence sufficiency 0.0/100, contamination posture 48.0/100, novelty posture 50.0/100, urgency 35.0/100, and escalation suitability 42.2/100. Bundle evidence sufficiency 0.0/100 (unknown), contradiction 0.0/100, confidence 18.1/100, uncertainty 42.4/100. Memory shaping was inactive_or_abstained and remained subordinate to live evidence. Orchestration readiness selected WaitForMoreLiveEvidence and still did not take execution ownership from Orbital. Primary branch verdict Suppress; Orbital-compatible verdict deferred.","challenge_findings":[{"summary":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e evidence sufficiency is only 0.0/100.","severity":"moderate","branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","finding_type":"branch_weak_evidence"},{"summary":"Policy challenge 'promotion_criteria' -> Tighten at concern 64.4/100.","severity":"moderate","finding_type":"policy_challenge"},{"summary":"Civitas memory review for '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' recommends 'tighten' from 3 hook(s).","severity":"high","branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","finding_type":"branch_policy_learning_receipt"},{"summary":"Memory shaping abstained: No historical branch memory was available for shaping.","severity":"low","branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","finding_type":"branch_memory_shaping_status"},{"summary":"Treat 'bundle' cautiously: 3 total memories, 1 poor-yield, 0 contamination, 0 false-novelty.","severity":"moderate","branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","finding_type":"branch_outcome_memory_influence"},{"summary":"Executive orchestration readiness selected WaitForMoreLiveEvidence with 0 guarded request decision(s).","severity":"low","branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","finding_type":"branch_orchestration_posture"}],"confidence_posture":"very_low","used_bundle_fields":["claims.claim_statement","claims.text_summary","claims.evidence_sufficiency","claims.contradiction","claims.corroboration","claims.confidence_summary","claims.admissibility_status","claims.supporting_evidence_refs.source_reliability","interventions.intervention_heuristics","evidence_sufficiency_summary","disagreement_map","confidence_summary","admissibility_metadata","behavioral_context","committee_context","replay_metadata","workspace_id","branch_memory_shaping_controls","branch_orchestration_controls","branch_orchestration_state","branch_governance_policy","branch_evidence_scorecard","branch_comparison_scorecard","branch_frontier_policy","branch_search_nudge_posture","branch_portfolio_posture","branch_replay_trace","branch_policy_variants","branch_shadow_evaluations","branch_outcome_memories","branch_strategic_retrospectives","branch_policy_learning_receipt","branch_artifacts","branches","candidate_branches","counter_branches","heat_annotations"],"uncertainty_posture":"low","contra_evidence_gaps":[],"recommended_followup":["Collect bounded disconfirming evidence against '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' before any merge-style promotion."],"branch_outcome_memory":{"records":[{"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","memory_id":"memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","branch_type":"bundle","correlation":{"final_verdict":"deferred","branch_verdicts":["suppress","request_disconfirming_evidence","weak_evidence"],"replay_trace_id":null,"source_memory_ids":[],"linked_judgment_ids":[],"governance_receipt_id":null,"primary_branch_verdict":"suppress","policy_learning_receipt_id":"policy-learning-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"},"observed_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197308645+00:00","recorded_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197308645+00:00","derived_from":"current_adjudication","outcome_type":"died","workspace_id":"unknown-workspace","outcome_reason":"The leading branch was deferred and did not survive current bounded governance.","policy_context":"Deferred branches should caution repeated operator attention without new evidence.","lineage_context":{"lineage_key":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","source_lane":"bundle","lineage_family":"bundle_family","linked_claim_ids":[],"parent_branch_id":null},"contract_version":"civitas.branch.outcome.memory.v1","evidence_summary":"The branch died under contradiction 4.0/100 and evidence 0.0/100.","audience_relevance_summary":null},{"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","memory_id":"memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","branch_type":"bundle","correlation":{"final_verdict":"deferred","branch_verdicts":["suppress","request_disconfirming_evidence","weak_evidence"],"replay_trace_id":null,"source_memory_ids":[],"linked_judgment_ids":[],"governance_receipt_id":null,"primary_branch_verdict":"suppress","policy_learning_receipt_id":"policy-learning-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"},"observed_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197308645+00:00","recorded_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197308645+00:00","derived_from":"current_adjudication","outcome_type":"contradiction_kill","workspace_id":"unknown-workspace","outcome_reason":"Contradiction pressure killed the branch before promotion.","policy_context":"Do not recycle this lineage without disconfirming repair.","lineage_context":{"lineage_key":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","source_lane":"bundle","lineage_family":"bundle_family","linked_claim_ids":[],"parent_branch_id":null},"contract_version":"civitas.branch.outcome.memory.v1","evidence_summary":"Contradiction 4.0/100 overran plausibility 24.1/100 and evidence 0.0/100.","audience_relevance_summary":null},{"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","memory_id":"memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield","branch_type":"bundle","correlation":{"final_verdict":"deferred","branch_verdicts":["suppress","request_disconfirming_evidence","weak_evidence"],"replay_trace_id":null,"source_memory_ids":[],"linked_judgment_ids":[],"governance_receipt_id":null,"primary_branch_verdict":"suppress","policy_learning_receipt_id":"policy-learning-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"},"observed_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197308645+00:00","recorded_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197308645+00:00","derived_from":"current_adjudication","outcome_type":"low_yield","workspace_id":"unknown-workspace","outcome_reason":"The branch consumed attention without enough evidence lift.","policy_context":"Caution low-yield branch classes in future policy review.","lineage_context":{"lineage_key":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","source_lane":"bundle","lineage_family":"bundle_family","linked_claim_ids":[],"parent_branch_id":null},"contract_version":"civitas.branch.outcome.memory.v1","evidence_summary":"Weak evidence or missing disconfirmation kept the branch below merge quality despite branch activity.","audience_relevance_summary":"Treat similar branches cautiously because they tend to spend attention without producing publishable value."}],"workspace_id":"unknown-workspace","bounded_scope":"Bounded operational branch-outcome memory only. This is not full autobiographical HCM/HSAM memory and not unconstrained doctrine mutation.","persistence_surface":"Persisted in the structured adjudication response and the existing Civitas herald log row.","retrospective_count":0,"current_record_count":3,"ingested_record_count":0},"branch_outcome_summary":{"bounded_scope":"Bounded operational branch-outcome memory only. This is not full autobiographical HCM/HSAM memory and not unconstrained doctrine mutation.","total_records":3,"merge_patterns":[],"outcome_counts":[{"count":1,"outcome_type":"died"},{"count":1,"outcome_type":"contradiction_kill"},{"count":1,"outcome_type":"low_yield"}],"branch_type_yield":[{"branch_type":"bundle","success_rate":0.0,"total_records":3,"high_value_count":0,"poor_yield_count":1,"contamination_count":0,"false_novelty_count":0,"successful_merge_count":0,"contradiction_kill_count":2}],"most_common_kill_reasons":[{"count":1,"summary":"Contradiction pressure killed the branch before promotion. occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"Contradiction pressure killed the branch before promotion.","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill"]},{"count":1,"summary":"The branch consumed attention without enough evidence lift. occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"The branch consumed attention without enough evidence lift.","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"]},{"count":1,"summary":"The leading branch was deferred and did not survive current bounded governance. occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"The leading branch was deferred and did not survive current bounded governance.","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died"]}],"recurring_failure_patterns":[{"count":3,"summary":"bundle occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"bundle","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"]}],"contradiction_kill_patterns":[{"count":1,"summary":"bundle_family occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"bundle_family","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill"]}],"repeated_false_novelty_classes":[],"repeated_contamination_families":[],"successful_disconfirming_patterns":[]},"branch_primary_verdict":"suppress","policy_artifact_intake":{"evidence":null,"frontier":null,"portfolio":null,"comparison":null,"search_nudge":null},"branch_reflexive_report":{"blockers":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e still lacks enough evidence depth for a merge-style verdict."],"next_actions":["Collect bounded disconfirming evidence against '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' before any merge-style promotion."],"bounded_scope":"Civitas judged only the supplied Orbital bundle and branch artifacts. It did not retrieve, crawl, or own branch generation. HCM / HSAM-inspired shaping used only bounded, replayable branch memory and remained subordinate to live evidence.","branch_verdicts":["suppress","request_disconfirming_evidence","weak_evidence"],"primary_verdict":"suppress","decisive_signals":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e plausibility 24.1, evidence 0.0, contradiction 4.0, contamination 48.0.","Bundle evidence 0.0/100, contradiction 0.0/100, admissibility 'context_only' with 0% admissible share."],"primary_branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","contamination_notes":[],"contradiction_notes":[]},"branch_governance_receipt":null,"branch_outcome_governance":{"influences":[{"effect":"caution","summary":"Treat 'bundle' cautiously: 3 total memories, 1 poor-yield, 0 contamination, 0 false-novelty.","branch_type":"bundle","outcome_type":"low_yield","influence_type":"historical_low_yield_branch_type","supporting_memory_ids":[]}],"bounded_scope":"Bounded operational branch-outcome memory only. This is not full autobiographical HCM/HSAM memory and not unconstrained doctrine mutation.","repeated_false_novelty_classes":[],"historical_caution_branch_types":["bundle"],"repeated_contamination_patterns":[],"successful_disconfirming_patterns":[]},"branch_orchestration_receipt":{"active":false,"posture":"wait_for_more_live_evidence","controls":{"max_depth":2,"max_concurrency":1,"cooldown_minutes":90,"tool_call_budget":2,"repeated_request_cap":2,"deny_recursive_runaway":true,"fatigue_window_minutes":360,"per_cycle_decision_cap":2,"min_live_evidence_floor":45.0,"min_shaping_signal_floor":0.45,"max_escalations_per_cycle":1},"abstained":true,"reasoning":["Primary branch '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' carries support 18.1/100, uncertainty 42.4/100, acceptance headroom 0.0/100.","Raw posture hinted PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence; shaped posture hinted PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence."],"replayable":false,"correlation":{"bundle_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","adjudication_id":"civitas-adj-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-1778399946197","replay_trace_id":null,"primary_branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","governance_receipt_id":null,"policy_learning_receipt_id":"policy-learning-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"},"bounded_scope":"Executive orchestration readiness only. Civitas can express bounded, replayable, inspectable orchestration posture over Orbital-owned branch execution, but it does not execute branches, crawl, or become an unconstrained executive agent. Aegis remains the future enforcement and policy-boundary layer.","budget_status":{"max_depth":2,"active_depth":0,"depth_granted":0,"cooldown_active":false,"depth_remaining":2,"depth_requested":0,"max_concurrency":1,"concurrency_in_use":0,"escalation_granted":0,"escalation_requested":0,"recent_request_count":0,"repeated_request_cap":2,"concurrency_remaining":1,"per_cycle_decision_cap":2,"tool_call_budget_granted":0,"max_escalations_per_cycle":1,"cooldown_remaining_minutes":0,"tool_call_budget_remaining":2,"tool_call_budget_requested":0,"decisions_issued_this_cycle":0,"escalations_issued_this_cycle":0,"escalations_remaining_this_cycle":1},"memory_inputs":["Treat 'bundle' cautiously: 3 total memories, 1 poor-yield, 0 contamination, 0 false-novelty."],"policy_inputs":["promotion_criteria -> Tighten"],"tool_requests":[],"abstain_reason":"Live evidence is below the orchestration floor, so Civitas abstains from deeper request issuance.","shaping_inputs":["No historical branch memory was available for shaping."],"budget_receipts":[],"evidence_inputs":{"final_verdict":"deferred","support_score":18.1,"primary_verdict":"suppress","uncertainty_score":42.4,"acceptance_headroom":0.0},"guardrails_fired":["live_evidence_floor_guardrail"],"withheld_actions":["No additional exploration request was issued because live evidence remains too weak.","The shaped posture PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence was not issued because the final guarded posture settled on WaitForMoreLiveEvidence.","A disconfirming-evidence request was considered but not made primary in this cycle."],"orchestration_mode":"bounded_executive_orchestration_readiness","raw_posture_summary":"Raw primary posture for '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' was PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence from plausibility 24.1, contradiction 4.0, evidence 0.0, escalation 42.2.","supporting_postures":["reduce_budget_on_low_yield_branch_class"],"shaped_posture_summary":"Memory-shaped primary posture for '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' was PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence from plausibility 24.1, contradiction 4.0, evidence 0.0, escalation 42.2.","memory_shaping_influence_weight":0.0},"branch_outcome_operator_view":{"bounded_scope":"Bounded operational branch-outcome memory only. This is not full autobiographical HCM/HSAM memory and not unconstrained doctrine mutation.","branch_outcomes_by_type":[{"count":1,"outcome_type":"died"},{"count":1,"outcome_type":"contradiction_kill"},{"count":1,"outcome_type":"low_yield"}],"most_common_kill_reasons":[{"count":1,"summary":"Contradiction pressure killed the branch before promotion. occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"Contradiction pressure killed the branch before promotion.","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill"]},{"count":1,"summary":"The branch consumed attention without enough evidence lift. occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"The branch consumed attention without enough evidence lift.","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"]},{"count":1,"summary":"The leading branch was deferred and did not survive current bounded governance. occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"The leading branch was deferred and did not survive current bounded governance.","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died"]}],"top_successful_branch_classes":[],"repeated_wasted_attention_patterns":[{"count":3,"summary":"bundle occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"bundle","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"]}],"contamination_false_novelty_patterns":[]},"branch_memory_shaping_receipt":{"active":false,"effects":[{"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","raw_plausibility":24.1,"raw_contradiction":4.0,"shaped_plausibility":24.1,"repeat_waste_penalty":0.0,"shaped_contradiction":4.0,"confidence_adjustment":0.0,"merge_caution_adjustment":0.0,"raw_escalation_suitability":42.2,"shaped_escalation_suitability":42.2,"live_evidence_outweighed_memory":false}],"summary":["No historical branch memory was available for shaping."],"controls":{"confidence_floor":0.4,"max_shaping_weight":0.12,"retrieval_count_cap":6,"replayability_required":true,"min_live_evidence_floor":45.0,"freshness_half_life_days":30.0,"persistence_saturation_count":3},"abstained":true,"replayable":true,"shaping_mode":"bounded_hcm_hsam_inspired_branch_memory_shaping","bounded_scope":"HCM / HSAM-inspired shaping only. Memory shaping is bounded, inspectable, replayable, abstain-capable, and subordinate to live evidence. It is not full autobiographical executive memory or unconstrained doctrine rewriting.","abstain_reason":"No historical branch memory was available for shaping.","applied_signals":[],"retrieved_items":[],"influence_capped":false,"live_evidence_floor_met":false,"recency_persistence_summary":"Freshness uses a 30.0-day half-life while persistence saturates after 3 matching memories."},"branch_policy_learning_receipt":{"reasons":["Historical branch failures or false convergence still justify a tighter policy posture.","Treat 'bundle' cautiously: 3 total memories, 1 poor-yield, 0 contamination, 0 false-novelty."],"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","issued_at":"2026-05-10T07:59:06.197353750+00:00","receipt_id":"policy-learning-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","source_kind":"civitas_memory_review","memory_hook_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"],"contract_version":"orbital.branch.policy.learning.receipt.v1","linked_judgments":[],"challenge_summary":{"max_waste_score":0.8,"failure_hook_count":3,"top_failure_patterns":[{"count":3,"summary":"bundle occurred 1 time(s) across branches [\"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e\"].","pattern_key":"bundle","example_branch_ids":["39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e"],"supporting_memory_ids":["memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-contradiction_kill","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-died","memory-unknown-workspace-39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e-low_yield"]}],"total_memory_records":3,"governance_disposition":null,"false_convergence_count":0,"repeated_false_novelty_classes":[],"historical_caution_branch_types":["bundle"],"repeated_contamination_patterns":[],"successful_disconfirming_patterns":[]},"recommended_posture":"tighten","future_hcm_hsam_insertion_points":{"note":"Reserved insertion points only; full HCM/HSAM shaping is not active.","active":false,"hcm_slot":"branch_policy_outcome_memory_v1","hsam_slot":"branch_family_pattern_memory_v1"}},"branch_orchestration_audit_view":{"raw_posture":"prioritize_disconfirming_evidence","what_changed":["Guardrails overrode the shaped posture PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence and forced the final posture to WaitForMoreLiveEvidence."],"bounded_scope":"Executive orchestration readiness only. Civitas can express bounded, replayable, inspectable orchestration posture over Orbital-owned branch execution, but it does not execute branches, crawl, or become an unconstrained executive agent. Aegis remains the future enforcement and policy-boundary layer.","branch_deltas":[{"branch_id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","raw_plausibility":24.1,"raw_posture_hint":"prioritize_disconfirming_evidence","raw_contradiction":4.0,"shaped_plausibility":24.1,"shaped_posture_hint":"prioritize_disconfirming_evidence","shaped_contradiction":4.0,"raw_escalation_suitability":42.2,"shaped_escalation_suitability":42.2}],"final_posture":"wait_for_more_live_evidence","shaped_posture":"prioritize_disconfirming_evidence","shaping_capped":false,"shaping_abstained":true,"changed_by_shaping":false,"what_did_not_change":["Orbital still owns branch execution and exploration; Civitas only emits bounded posture and requests.","No policy was silently rewritten and no recursive execution loop was started.","Live evidence remained the primary driver of the final orchestration posture."]},"branch_orchestration_operator_view":{"posture":"wait_for_more_live_evidence","system_state":"waiting_for_evidence","bounded_scope":"Executive orchestration readiness only. Civitas can express bounded, replayable, inspectable orchestration posture over Orbital-owned branch execution, but it does not execute branches, crawl, or become an unconstrained executive agent. Aegis remains the future enforcement and policy-boundary layer.","memory_status":"memory_shaping_abstained:No historical branch memory was available for shaping.","policy_status":"policy_stable_under_current_bundle","budget_receipts":[],"recent_decisions":[],"rationale_summary":["Primary branch '39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e' carries support 18.1/100, uncertainty 42.4/100, acceptance headroom 0.0/100.","Raw posture hinted PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence; shaped posture hinted PrioritizeDisconfirmingEvidence."],"active_tool_budget":{"max_depth":2,"active_depth":0,"depth_granted":0,"cooldown_active":false,"depth_remaining":2,"depth_requested":0,"max_concurrency":1,"concurrency_in_use":0,"escalation_granted":0,"escalation_requested":0,"recent_request_count":0,"repeated_request_cap":2,"concurrency_remaining":1,"per_cycle_decision_cap":2,"tool_call_budget_granted":0,"max_escalations_per_cycle":1,"cooldown_remaining_minutes":0,"tool_call_budget_remaining":2,"tool_call_budget_requested":0,"decisions_issued_this_cycle":0,"escalations_issued_this_cycle":0,"escalations_remaining_this_cycle":1},"outstanding_requests":[],"hold_or_abstain_reasons":["Live evidence is below the orchestration floor, so Civitas abstains from deeper request issuance.","live_evidence_floor_guardrail"]},"branch_memory_shaping_operator_view":{"active":false,"bounded_scope":"HCM / HSAM-inspired shaping only. Memory shaping is bounded, inspectable, replayable, abstain-capable, and subordinate to live evidence. It is not full autobiographical executive memory or unconstrained doctrine rewriting.","shaping_status":"abstained","abstention_cases":["No historical branch memory was available for shaping."],"shaping_strength_posture":"weak","retrieved_pattern_summary":[],"applied_adjustment_summary":[]}},"request_metadata":{"request_id":"auto-70b9221305b149cbafd7fe8054954539","window_end":"2026-05-11T00:00:00+00:00","packet_type":"governance_heartbeat","trigger_kind":"manual","window_start":"2026-05-04T00:00:00+00:00","submitted_from":"orbital","submission_mode":"automatic"},"response_metadata":{"attempt":1,"elapsed_ms":24.59,"status_code":200,"content_type":"application/json"},"runtime_metadata":{"authority":"ask-civitas-orbital","transport":"https_rest_mtls","packet_type":"governance_heartbeat","fallback_active":false,"submission_mode":"automatic","expected_authority":"ask-civitas-orbital"},"error_message":null,"handoff_bundle":{"id":"39260d6d-773d-435c-81cc-293d8ad1345e","title":"Civitas governed bundle — 2026-05-11","bundle_kind":"civitas_handoff","status":"ready","readiness_state":"needs_more_evidence","readiness_summary":"Bundle is replayable but not yet ready for adjudication challenge.","window_start":"2026-05-04T00:00:00Z","window_end":"2026-05-11T00:00:00Z","bundle_version":"prompt_s4_v1","generated_by":"system:civitas_automation","generated_at":"2026-05-10T03:45:48.158469Z","claim_count":0,"intervention_count":6,"evidence_sufficiency_score":6.0,"confidence_score":24.0,"contradiction_score":0.0,"automation_state":"ineligible","automation_summary":"Bundle does not meet the bounded automatic adjudication rules.","generated_automatically":true,"eligible_for_auto_submission":false,"artifact_refs":[{"artifact_kind":"intervention","artifact_type":"message_push","artifact_id":"a6b7f4ee-95dd-4909-aa86-a8f0d1ea0781","title":"Tighten posture around the governed weak points","status":"draft","generated_at":"2026-05-09T06:12:19.372870+00:00","metadata":{"outcome_count":0}},{"artifact_kind":"intervention","artifact_type":"pack_deployment","artifact_id":"d27d4457-5863-40b8-8431-507effe50092","title":"Deploy a proof-pack against the main approval blocker","status":"draft","generated_at":"2026-05-09T06:12:19.372870+00:00","metadata":{"outcome_count":0}},{"artifact_kind":"intervention","artifact_type":"narrative_shift","artifact_id":"2ae9b6d6-78b7-4bad-aa09-a7234b079388","title":"Reframe DeepTCR: Deep Learning to Decode T‑Cell Receptor Sequences into the buyer proof standard","status":"draft","generated_at":"2026-05-09T06:12:19.372870+00:00","metadata":{"outcome_count":0}},{"artifact_kind":"intervention","artifact_type":"message_push","artifact_id":"c80ed9d6-0ef1-41dd-bf4e-7a0a35d55c91","title":"Tighten posture around the governed weak points","status":"draft","generated_at":"2026-05-08T22:11:23.921050+00:00","metadata":{"outcome_count":0}},{"artifact_kind":"intervention","artifact_type":"pack_deployment","artifact_id":"f667e896-c99f-4ebf-b6a7-211f03785469","title":"Deploy a proof-pack against the main approval blocker","status":"draft","generated_at":"2026-05-08T22:11:23.921050+00:00","metadata":{"outcome_count":0}},{"artifact_kind":"intervention","artifact_type":"narrative_shift","artifact_id":"4f81cc34-565b-476a-8a6a-f902f5eddf17","title":"Reframe AI’s Full Life Cycle Environmental Footprint into the buyer proof standard","status":"draft","generated_at":"2026-05-08T22:11:23.921050+00:00","metadata":{"outcome_count":0}},{"artifact_kind":"branch","artifact_type":"branch_frontier_context","artifact_id":"f364afa7-1c27-4302-81df-f140487cc5e3","title":"Hunter branch: probe new source cluster around AI Strategy in Worlds of Imperfect Information: Theme centered on amounts imperfect information, back his board-game, beating human players. via high-authority supporting sources","status":"ACTIVE","generated_at":"2026-05-09T06:06:56.058369+00:00","metadata":{"market_rank":1,"market_score":0.3353,"replay_trace_id":"0bc95e16-7324-4be5-aa1d-a265e53d6bdb"}}],"created_at":"2026-05-10T03:45:48.159512Z"},"proposal_lineage_refs":[]}